.

Overthinking: Why More Thinking Doesn’t Always Lead to Better Decisions

minimalist interior with art and vase

You have compared the options, made the list, asked two friends, and somehow you still do not feel ready to decide. If that sounds familiar, you are in good company. Thinking carefully is a strength. But there is a point at which additional thinking stops adding clarity and starts adding doubt.

What psychology tells us

Psychologist Barry Schwartz and colleagues described two broad decision styles. Maximisers aim to find the best possible option, while satisficers look for one that is good enough for their needs. In their research, people who tended to maximise often reported less satisfaction with their choices and more regret afterwards, even when their outcomes were objectively good.

A related idea is choice overload: the experience of feeling less sure, or less satisfied, when faced with many options. Researchers have found that this effect varies across situations, so it is not universal. Still, it points to something many of us recognise. More options and more information do not automatically make a decision feel easier.

There is also a quiet emotional layer. We often keep thinking because we hope to remove all uncertainty, and most real decisions simply do not allow that. The mind keeps searching for certainty that is not available.

A small practice: criteria, limit, and a good-enough line

Try this the next time a decision keeps circling. It takes about ten minutes.

  1. Name your criteria. Write down the two or three things that matter most to you here, such as cost, time, or how a choice fits your values. Everything else becomes secondary.
  2. Set a limit. Decide in advance how long you will gather information, and when you will choose. A deadline turns an open loop into a closed one.
  3. Draw a good-enough line. Ask yourself: “What would a good-enough option look like?” When one meets that line, you are allowed to choose it.

It can also help to say your decision out loud to someone you trust, simply to hear how it sounds. Often, you will notice a quiet preference you had already formed.

Reflect for a moment

  • Which decision have you been thinking about for longer than it needs?
  • What would “good enough” look like for it?
  • What are you hoping to feel once you have decided, and could you reach for that feeling in another way?

Save this for the next time your thoughts start going in circles. Clear decisions rarely come from certainty. More often, they come from knowing what matters to you and giving yourself permission to choose.

If you would like a guided way to explore this, THINK LESS, our guided psychological workbook on overthinking, and the Decision Clarity Tool are designed around Learn, Reflect, Apply. They are educational and wellbeing-oriented tools, not a substitute for professional care. If repetitive thoughts feel constant or begin to affect your sleep, work or relationships, speaking with a doctor or psychologist is a sensible next step.

Further reading: Schwartz et al. (2002), Maximizing versus satisficing: Happiness is a matter of choice, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology; Scheibehenne et al. (2010), Can there ever be too many options? A meta-analytic review of choice overload, Journal of Consumer Research.

This article is educational and meant for general self-reflection. It is not therapy, and it does not replace professional psychological or medical support.

Free newsletter + welcome gift

Small tools. Meaningful reflection.

Join the free newsletter and receive Make Room, a 10-minute reset tool for a full mind, as your welcome gift. Plus new articles and tools from Mindaria Co., straight to your inbox.

Free to join. Cancel anytime. Please confirm your email address, and your download link arrives in your welcome email. More about Make Room

Make Room – The 10-Minute Reset, free welcome gift