Overthinking & Emotions: Why Our Minds Go in Circles

The day is over, the house is quiet, and yet your mind is replaying a single sentence from a conversation that happened hours ago.
Overthinking is one of the most common experiences people describe, and it is rarely a sign that something is wrong with you. More often, it is a mind trying very hard to make sense of something that matters.
What psychology tells us
Psychologists often separate two kinds of repetitive thinking:
- Reflection moves toward understanding. It asks what happened, what it means and what could be done next.
- Rumination circles. It returns to the same thoughts, the same questions and the same feelings without arriving anywhere new.
The work of psychologist Susan Nolen-Hoeksema, who developed the response styles theory, showed that repeatedly focusing on how we feel and why we feel that way can keep difficult emotions going for longer. The trouble is that rumination can feel like problem-solving. It seems productive, so we keep going.
Emotions are closely tied to this loop. Strong feelings tell us that something matters, and the mind responds by turning it over and over. A useful question is therefore not “How do I stop thinking?” but “What is this thinking trying to tell me, and is it still giving me anything new?”
There is also encouraging research on the emotional side. In a well-known study from 2007, Matthew Lieberman and colleagues found that putting feelings into words was associated with reduced activity in the amygdala, a brain region involved in emotional reactivity. Naming what we feel does not make it disappear, but it can take some of the intensity out of the moment.
A small practice: name, notice, next step
This takes about five minutes and works best on paper.
- Name it. Find a precise word for what you feel. “Disappointed”, “uncertain” or “overwhelmed” often says more than “bad” or “stressed”.
- Notice the loop. Write down the thought that keeps returning, starting with “I notice I’m thinking that…”. This small phrasing creates a little distance between you and the thought.
- Choose a next step. If there is something you can do, write down one small action. If there is not, set a short “thinking window” for later (ten minutes, same time each day) and let the thought wait until then.
Scheduling worry time is an approach that has been studied in clinical research and can help some people spend less of the day in repetitive thinking. It is not a fix for everything, but it can be a gentle way to hold a thought without feeding it all evening.
A change of scene helps many people too. A short walk, a glass of water or a different room can interrupt the loop and give your mind something else to work with.
Reflect for a moment
- When your mind starts to circle, which feeling is usually underneath?
- Is the thought you keep returning to asking for understanding, or for action?
- What would it feel like to let one thought wait until tomorrow?
Save this for the next time your thoughts start going in circles. Overthinking is not something to fight. It is a pattern we can learn to notice, one calm moment at a time.
Mandaria Co. creates guided reflection tools built on Learn, Reflect, Apply. They are educational and wellbeing-oriented, not a substitute for professional care. If repetitive thoughts feel constant, are hard to control, or begin to affect your sleep, work or relationships, speaking with a doctor or psychologist is a sensible and worthwhile step.
Further reading: Nolen-Hoeksema (1991), Responses to depression and their effects on the duration of depressive episodes; Lieberman et al. (2007), Putting feelings into words, Psychological Science; Borkovec et al. (1983) on stimulus control for worry.
